• Thoughts

The best strategy is to keep working with people you trust

In recurring relationships, the opportunity to cooperate again is crucial. Beyond response strategies, one must think about who to stay with for the long term.

Repeated cooperation with people we trust becomes a source of lasting strength.

In the Prisoner's Dilemma, betraying is advantageous. If the other person betrays me, it is better for me to betray them too, and even if the other person cooperates with me, betraying alone can bring greater profit. If the game is played only once, there is little reason to trust the opponent.


However, most of our lives do not end with a single game. We meet the person we worked with today again tomorrow, and we meet the person we met in this project again in the next. The same goes for friends, colleagues, and partners.


Life is not a single Prisoner's Dilemma, but closer to a repeated game.

In a repeated game, the strategy changes

Then, how should one behave in a repeated game?


In the 1980s, Robert Axelrod held a repeated Prisoner's Dilemma tournament. Various researchers submitted their own strategies, and one strategy performed particularly well: Tit for Tat. It starts by cooperating. If the opponent cooperates, it cooperates again. If the opponent betrays, it betrays in the next round.


And if the opponent cooperates again, it cooperates again. It simply mirrors the opponent's immediately preceding action.


There are a few interesting characteristics here. It never betrays first. Yet, it does not simply keep getting taken advantage of. If the opponent betrays, it responds accordingly in the next turn.


However, it does not make an enemy for life out of someone who betrayed once. If the opponent cooperates again, it also cooperates again.

What is as important as responding is cooperating again

I believe the last part is especially important here. It is the ability to forgive. Once we are hurt by someone, we tend to remain wary of them. "They acted like that last time, so they'll do it again this time." When we think that way, I too continue to act defensively. The other person also begins to be wary of me.


One betrayal creates the next betrayal, and that betrayal creates yet another. Eventually, a relationship is formed where both parties lose.

Therefore, in recurring relationships, it is just as important to leave room for the opportunity to cooperate again as it is to respond to betrayal.

This is not about living only as a 'nice person.' Cooperate first, but do not just be a victim. Respond to betrayal, but reach out again if the other person returns.


But when I tell this story to people, I get an interesting reaction. "But is that opponent someone you know?" This question might be the key. In the Prisoner's Dilemma, one worries about which strategy to use with a given opponent.

In reality, you can also choose who to be with

Because in reality, you can also choose who to keep playing the game with. No matter how good a strategy you use against someone who constantly betrays, the relationship incurs a high cost.


Conversely, if you meet someone who cooperates first and can cooperate again even after a mistake, complex strategies themselves might not be necessary. Cooperating dozens of times with a good person can produce far greater results than gaining a little more from a single transaction.

The best strategy is to cooperate with a good person for a long time

Therefore, there is something as important as contemplating how to treat people: deciding who to form recurring relationships with. Someone who can be trusted first. Someone who does not take that trust for granted. Someone who knows how to cooperate again when they have made a mistake. And becoming that kind of person myself.


Perhaps the strongest strategy in a repeated game is not the method of defeating the opponent. It is meeting a trustworthy person and building a relationship where you can cooperate for a long time.

Choosing the right person to play the game with before worrying about the game's strategy. I believe that is the larger strategy we can choose.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts on this article.

Comment inquiries

Loading comments…

A Trip to Suncheon and Yeosu, Day 3

The last day, ending with some studying and a run.

Seungmin Yang

A Trip to Suncheon and Yeosu, Day 2

The second day of the trip, from a clear morning by the sea to sunset and dusk on Baekyado Island.

Seungmin Yang

A Trip to Suncheon and Yeosu

A trip to Suncheon and Yeosu.

SkyDive Team
See all